• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Spencer Critchley

  • Home
  • About
  • Media Appearances
    • Broadcast Appearances
    • Print & Web Coverage
    • My Reporting & Commentary
    • Podcast
    • “Saving Democracy” Events
    • News: Real or Fake?
    • Hallmarks of a #BadArgument
  • Music
  • Photos
  • Subscribe
  • Contact

Politics & Society

The GOP’s Long March to Minority Rule

June 25, 2022 by Spencer Critchley

Closeup of menacing-looking tiger
Image: iStock

The Supreme Court’s overturning of Roe v. Wade is a milestone in the Republican Party’s long march from democracy to minority rule. They’re following the political logic that flows from economic policies that can’t draw majority support.

From the 1930s to the ’60s, Republicans were in the political wilderness, trying somehow to win the votes of working people with policies that serve wealthy people — whatever the intentions of those backing the policies. Some were motivated by simple greed, others by sincere but mistaken good intentions (results have been stubbornly better under the Democrats’ Keynesian policies than the Republicans’ Hayekian ones).

But in the ’60s the GOP was able to win over the cultural conservatives and racists who abandoned the Democrats.*

The GOP stopped campaigning on its losing economic policies and switched to riding the tiger of cultural/racial fear and anger. Hence the focus ever since on God, guns, gays, abortion, drugs, crime, welfare, and thinly veiled racism (starting with Nixon’s notorious Southern Strategy).

That change, with big assists from right-wing media, corporation- and billionaire-funded interest groups and think tanks, and an often hapless Democratic Party, was enough to win majorities in many states and districts, though still not a national majority.

But it provided enough leverage for gerrymandering, voter suppression, intimidation, and corruption to make minority rule a realistic alternative. So that’s where the logic of it all has led the GOP — and GOP leaders seem to be fine with it. They were willing to follow Donald Trump all the way to fascism, and now show every sign of following whoever his successor might be.

We’ve assumed they were still riding the tiger because, as the saying goes, they were afraid to dismount — the tiger will eat you. But it turns out they don’t mind the ride at all, as long as it gets them where they want to go.

If riding the tiger doesn’t win elections, that’s OK, if elections don’t matter much any more. No more need to talk about policies; those were officially abandoned in 2020 and haven’t been missed.

Now, there is only the pursuit of power.

* The states of the former Confederacy and some others flipped from blue to red between the 1964 and ’68 presidential elections, won by Lyndon Johnson and Richard Nixon respectively. Democratic control of Congress extended to 1994, when Newt Gingrich’s scorched-earth campaign against Democrats and the institution itself launched the current era of Republican dominance there.

Filed Under: Politics & Society

Great Replacement Theory: Just the Latest Version of an Ancient Lie

May 17, 2022 by Spencer Critchley

Media coverage of Great Replacement Theory traces its roots through the Trump years to the Southern Strategy of the 1960s. But the legacy can be measured not in years but centuries. It’s the same lie told by every demagogue ever: Foreigners are coming and only I can save you — and your children! That angle comes straight from the Blood Libel against Jews, always a go-to for the worst among us.

Simon of Trent by Pietro Stafanoni. Public domain via Wikimedia Commons

It copies a pattern set in 1475, when then-new printing technology was used to mass produce the lie that Jews had tortured and murdered little Simon of Trent, which led to the actual torture, murder, and expulsion of local Jewish families. Simon would be venerated as a saint, his death made another Crucifixion, and exploited the same way.

The deliberate promotion of fear and hatred of black people goes back to a 17th-18th century shortage of slaves, who at the time might come from almost anywhere. There was an opportunity to solve the shortage by kidnapping Africans. To justify that, the concept of a racial hierarchy based on physical characteristics like skin color was invented. (Excellent sources of this history are Edward E. Baptist’s The Half Has Never Been Told and Jill LePore’s These Truths.)

It was supported with bogus racial science and religion, promoted through print, political campaigns, and in churches — the Southern Baptist Convention, for example, was formed (in 1845) in protest over the abolition movement.

Previously, slavery had been commonplace, but by the late 18th-19th century had widely come to be seen as wrong and shameful. Slaveholders lived in ever greater terror of an uprising, or a moral reckoning. They responded with vicious self-justification, Including the casting of their own sins into black people as supposedly deserving their fate, and the enlistment of God in their unholy enterprise as its supposed designer.

Meanwhile many non-slaveholders were complicit, content to participate in the profits while trying not to think too hard about how those profits were made.

The cruelty, guilt, shame, and fear were passed down the generations, long past the Civil War, through Jim Crow, through the Southern Strategy, to today’s demagogic politicians and media profiteers: the direct moral descendants of slaveholders and pogromists.

Still exploiting, and causing, the sacrifice of innocents.

Filed Under: Politics & Society

Latest podcast: Jade McGlynn on Putin’s Memory War

May 16, 2022 by Spencer Critchley

My guest on the latest episode of Dastardly Cleverness in the Service of Good has fascinating, important insights about Vladimir Putin’s “memory war:” a campaign to rewrite history with Russia at the center of the world stage. That campaign is being enacted with horrific violence in Ukraine, but is pursued in different ways around the world, including in the United States.

Dr. Jade McGlynn is a senior researcher with the Monterey Initiative in Russian Studies at MIIS, a former lecturer in Russian at Oxford University, and a contributor to Foreign Policy, The Telegraph, The Spectator, and others. She’s the author of The Kremlin’s Memory Makers, coming soon from Bloomsbury, and is currently writing a second book, Putin’s Unreality.

You can listen on any podcast app or at the Dastardly Cleverness website.

Filed Under: Communication, Politics & Society

THIS is what it looks like when Democrats stand for something

April 20, 2022 by Spencer Critchley

Last time, I cited a textbook example of how Democrats lose elections by campaigning as bureaucrats instead of leaders.

This time, I’m happy to point to a textbook example of the opposite: Michigan State Senator Mallory McMorrow’s powerful denunciation of a false and hateful attack on her by a GOP colleague.

You may very well have seen it, since it’s gone viral. If you haven’t, I hope you’ll watch it now. It’s fantastic.

Why? Because McMorrow shows how you answer the all-too-pressing question of what Democrats stand for: You stand for it.

This wasn’t “messaging.” It was presence.

Too many educated but alienated Democrats, from left to center, struggle to conjure this simple but elusive phenomenon.

It isn’t McMorrow’s policies that are so persuasive here, the packets of information being transmitted from her brain to our brains. It’s her obvious, full-body, bone-deep commitment to the values behind those policies.

I’ll bet there are plenty of voters who disagree with some of her policies who would still vote for her. Most voters don’t actually care about much about policies, or even understand them very well. They care about what McMorrow showed them.

I sure hope the many Democratic politicians studying her video right now can see what that is.

Filed Under: Communication, Leadership & Management, Politics & Society Tagged With: Democratic Party

Here’s why Democrats lose so many elections they should win

April 6, 2022 by Spencer Critchley

DNC chair Jaime Harrison on Morning Joe, April 6, 2022

A textbook example this morning of why Democrats lose elections they should win. MSNBC’s “Morning Joe” played a clip of Barack Obama being asked what Democrats should do in the midterms. He can answer in one simple—and true—sentence: “We’ve got a story to tell, just gotta tell it.”

Host Joe Scarborough then asked DNC chair Jaime Harrison—and this is not to single him out, because he is far from alone—what that story is. Harrison’s answer was not a story. As usual for Democrats these days, it was a long list of bullet points.

First there was a wonky wind-up, indicating that there would be no answer to the simple question, “What is the story?”

“Well, you know, Joe, the contrast is an important one. Because Joe, you know, elections are about contrasts.”

Then came the bullet points.

[Read more…] about Here’s why Democrats lose so many elections they should win

Filed Under: Communication, Politics & Society

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 34
  • Go to Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

Search This Site

Broadcast Appearances

Spencer Critchley on Spectrum News 1 LA

Book

Patriots of Two Nations by Spencer Critchley
Kindle & paperback at Amazon. Audio book at Audible. EPUB format here.

New Music: Jailbreak

Cover image for the song "Jailbreak:" a ruined motel by the side of a lonely desert road.

Podcast

Dastardly Cleverness in the Service of Good

Social Media

Substack

YouTube

Music: The Critchleys

The Critchleys: Owen and Spencer Critchley

About Me

Spencer Critchley

Jump to Recent Posts

New Music: The Desert Mothers

The True Crisis

Outside in the Rain

The Liberal Backbone

Slowly and then all at once

On the Podcast: A Letter to a Friend Voting for Trump

“The War of the Worldviews” at TedX Pugwash

Recent Comments

  • terry rankin on “The War of the Worldviews” at TedX Pugwash
  • Spencer Critchley on Why Biden was right to link MAGA, the Confederacy & the Axis in his SOTU address
  • Spencer Critchley on Why Biden was right to link MAGA, the Confederacy & the Axis in his SOTU address
  • Scott Sexton on Why Biden was right to link MAGA, the Confederacy & the Axis in his SOTU address
  • Anonymous on Why Biden was right to link MAGA, the Confederacy & the Axis in his SOTU address

Photos

Spencer Critchley on Fox News' Cavuto
Barack Obama photo by Spencer Critchley
Bruce Springsteen photo by Spencer Critchley
Jay-Z photo by Spencer Critchley
Tiny American flag in crowd at political rally
Director Elizabeth Thompson & Composer/Audio Producer Spencer Critchley with the Emmy for the PBS documentary "Blink."

Find more photos here.

Privacy Policy

Learn how this site collects information and how you can control that.

© 2005–2026 Spencer Critchley